[IEEE1904.1] Proposed agenda is posted

[Glen Kramer <gkramer@xxxxxxxxxxxx>]

Dear Colleagues,

 

We have a total of 743 comments received against D1.0.

 

The comment break down by clause is shown below.

 

Clause	Technical*	Editorial	Total
0	0	3	3
1	0	12	12
2	1	1	2
3	1	9	10
4	8	3	11
5	33	20	53
6	45	30	75
7	8	2	10
8	87	47	134
9	97	38	135
10	59	18	77
11	34	9	43
12	90	20	110
13	62	6	68
	525	218	743

(* The number of Technical comments is likely to further increase, as editors are required to reclassify Editorial comments that propose technical change into Technical comments.)

 

A note on editorial comments:

At the meeting, we will try to accept all editorial comments in bulk. Accepting in bulk means that resolutions to all editorial comments that editors proposed will be accepted by a single motion. To make sure that no wrong or undesired changes are made to the draft, it is important for everyone to review the editorial comments and the proposed resolutions. If you have any disagreement or a concern about the proposed resolution, please inform Chief editor that the comment in question should be discussed individually and not processed in bulk. Hopefully, there will not be too many such cases.

 

 

A note on technical comments:

It will be very challenging to resolve 525 technical comments (available meeting time only allows 2.5 minutes per comment on average), while ensuring that due technical consideration is given to each comment.

Considering that it is quite likely that we will not have time to resolve all comments, I suggest that we organize our comment resolution such that we at least cover one key clause for each task force. This way, even if we run out of time, at least we will have a number of completely resolved clauses that will allow us to produce D1.1 (at least for these clauses), while the rest of clauses and remaining unresolved comments will simply carry over to the next draft.

 

Therefore in the proposed agenda, I ordered clauses as follows:

 

Day 1:

1.       C5 and 5A

2.       C6 and 6A

3.       C9 and 9A

4.       C0-C4 (if we have time, otherwise move to later days)

Day 2:

1.       C8

2.       C12

3.       C10

Day 3:

1.       C11

2.       C13

3.       C7

 

The proposed agenda is posted here: http://www.ieee1904.org/1/meeting_info/siepon_1012_agenda.pdf

As always, I welcome all suggestions for improvement.

 

 

Thank you,

Glen